Rather than do the sensible thing (i.e., burn the box and never speak of it), Mrs. Doe did what any retired librarian with a steel-trap mind would do: she went full detective.

Reactions were mixed. Gertrude Pillington, 72, called it “a stain on the neighborhood’s legacy.” But others quietly rallied to Mrs. Doe’s side.

“She made me write an apology letter to Mr. Snuggles,” Josh said. “And she kept the glow-in-the-dark trowel as ‘emotional damages.’ I don’t even want to know what she’s using it for.”

Josh explained that he had ordered the items for a bachelorette party gag but had entered the wrong house number. He begged for mercy. Mrs. Doe, a woman who once made a Boy Scout cry for returning a book late, did not flinch.

And with that, she closed the door—just as a faint, low hum began emanating from her garden shed.

By J. Wellington Wimbley Dateline: Maple Grove Estates

“Honestly, good for her,” said neighbor Patricia Meacham, 66. “She’s handled this with more class than I would have. I’d have opened a pop-up shop.”

“I’ve survived shingles, two tax audits, and a possum in the crawlspace,” she said. “This is just another Tuesday in Maple Grove. But if anyone asks, the trowel is for weeding .”

Mrs. Doe’s response? She is reportedly framing the coupon next to her late husband’s Purple Heart.

The device, which she refuses to name, vibrated off her coffee table, knocked over a framed photo of Senator Rafferty, and came to rest buzzing menacingly against the tail of her sleeping tabby, Mr. Snuggles. The cat, now in therapy, has not been the same since.

Moral of the story: Always double-check your delivery address. And never underestimate a librarian.